In recent years international lawyers and accountants have built a web of corporate opacity which has enabled tax avoidance and corruption on an alarming scale. Private financial wealth sitting on tax havens has grown to around US$ 21 trillion, of which $9trillion is from developing countries. Some minuscule jurisdictions, such as the Cayman Islands, have become the legal home to trillions of dollars of corporate assets, offering the unbeatable attractions of zero taxation plus secrecy. Some industries are now dominated by them: half the world’s shipping is registered there.
Tag: GAAR
NWK judgment analysed
Judgment in the case of Mariana Bosch and Ian McClelland v Commissioner for the South African Revenue Service (Case no A94/2012) was handed down on 20 November 2012 by a full bench of the Western Cape High Court. The main judgment was written by Davis J (Baartman J concurring) and a separate judgment was written by Waglay J. The matter was on appeal from the Tax Court.
Trusts – is the conduit principle in peril?
The announcement regarding trusts in the 2013 budget is notable for two reasons: its brevity and its lack of detail. Any comments made in advance of the publication of the first draft of the Taxation Laws Amendment Bill expected in June can therefore only be speculative.
What do Apple, Google and Starbucks have in common?
by Ingé Lamprecht Managing tax base erosion and profit shifting in a new world order. What do Apple, Google and Starbucks have in common? The US? Right. Adored by many South Africans? Right again. Moreover, these companies have all recently been under fire for not “paying their fair share” of taxes, especially in the UK. Yet they have all emphasised that they are following the tax laws to the letter.
Anti-avoidance: share repurchases through subsidiaries
Judgment was handed down on 16 November 2012 by the Tax Court in the case of A Ltd v Commissioner for the South African Revenue Service. The facts were as follows. A Ltd was a company listed on the JSE
Avoidance as accepted practice – Commissioner for the South African Revenue Service v NWK Ltd 2011 (2) SA 67 (SCA)
Judgment was handed down in the important case of Bosch and McCleland v Commissioner for the South African Revenue Service on 20 November 2012 by a full bench of the Western Cape High Court (a case we have previously reported on).
High Court interprets NWK judgment
Judgment in the case of Mariana Bosch and Ian McClelland v Commissioner for the South African Revenue Service (case no A94/2012) was handed down on 20 November 2012 by a full bench of the Western Cape High Court. The main judgment was written by Davis J (Baartman J concurring) and a separate judgment was written by Waglay J. The matter was on appeal from the Tax Court.
Sent packing – Sent v Commissioner of Taxation [2012] FCA 382)
Mr Eduard Sent (Sent) was sent packing by the Federal Court of Australia (FCA) on 16 April 2012, in an appeal against a decision by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (Tribunal) on whether some or all of a payment of $11,600,000 to an executive share trust (Trust) was assessable as income in the hands of Sent (Sent v Commissioner of Taxation [2012] FCA 382). While the taxation of share incentive schemes in Australia differs from the position in South Africa, the case does highlight certain principles that are equally applicable in South Africa.