Author: Daniel Areias & Johan Kotze (Bowman Gilfillan) All taxation , in one way or another, may impact upon fundamental human rights. However, to ensure that the imposition is not absolute, section 5 of the Promotion of Administrative Justice Act provides that every person, whose rights may have been materially and adversely affected by administrative action, may request written reasons for that action from the administrator responsible.
Category: Court Cases
SARS audits and taxpayers’ rights
Authors: Beric Croome & Jerome Brink (ENS) The Tax Administration Act, Act 28 of 2011 (‘the TAA’) came into effect on 1 October 2012. Its promulgation brought with it many changes to not only taxpayers’ rights and obligations but the reciprocal rights and obligations on the part of the South African Revenue Service (‘SARS’) in its continuous busines
Krok heir faces R228m tax bill
Pretoria – Mark Krok, billionaire heir to an apartheid-era skin-lightening company, will be about R228m poorer if the SA Revenue Service (Sars) and the Australian Tax Office (ATO) have their way. The Sunday Times reported that Sars, on behalf of the ATO, is seeking an order to ring-fence Krok’s local assets – including a R37.5m mansion in Clifton, Cape Town, as well as vast chunks of pharmaceutical company Aspen and casino company Tsogo Sun. In 2006, Australia kicked off Operation Wickenby, targeting high-profile tax evaders – and their lawyers and accountants – who have set up shell companies and trusts in tax havens to evade the Australian tax office. Maxim Krok, Mark’s estranged half-brother, has also come under the spotlight. In 2010, the ATO unleashed investigators to scrutinise his tax records.
Piercing the corporate veil
The recognition of a company as a separate juristic person, liable for its own tax (or other) debts, is an important principle relied on by taxpayers when implementing various transactions.
High Court Rejects Challenge of Exchange Control Ruling
Billionaire entrepreneur Mark Shuttleworth emigrated from the Republic in February 2001. Following his emigration, he made applications to transfer portions of his blocked funds from the Republic. In the second of these (in 2008) he was permitted to remit funds subject to a levy equal 10% of the amount remitted.
Shuttleworth wins some, loses some in court
Billionaire entrepreneur Mark Shuttleworth’s bid to have South Africa’s entire exchange control system declared unconstitutional has failed. The North Gauteng High Court on Thursday dismissed Shuttleworth’s application to strike down the whole of section 9 of the Currency and Exchange Act and all of the Exchange Control Regulations as unconstitutional.
Patricia De Lille conned by tax fraud
THE tax practitioner who defrauded Cape Town mayor Patricia de Lille of R80 000 has been found guilty on a multitude of charges including fraud and theft in the Wynberg Regional Court.
Disposal of shares by a special purpose vehicle
Judgment was handed down in the case of A (Pty) Ltd v Commissioner for the South African Revenue Service (case number 13003, as yet unreported) on 13 June 2013. The case involved the timeworn question of whether the receipts or accruals in respect of the disposal of a particular asset constitute gross income, or whether it is excluded as being capital in nature.
Patricia De Lille conned by tax fraud
THE tax practitioner who defrauded Cape Town mayor Patricia de Lille of R80 000 has been found guilty on a multitude of charges including fraud and theft in the Wynberg Regional Court. Linda Addison-Adams, 54, used various methods to con clients until one of her victims laid bare her suspicious conduct to the South African Revenue Service (SARS).
Mutual assistance provisions in double tax agreement between United Kingdom and South Africa
In the recent case of Ben Nevis (Holdings) Limited & Metlika Trading Limited v The Commissioners for HMRC (Her Majesty’s Revenue and Customs) [2013] EWCA, the Court of Appeal of England and Wales considered the interpretation of the mutual assistance provisions in the double tax agreement (DTA) between the United Kingdom (UK) and South Africa (SA).